Types of Fly Fishing Flies
Fly fishing expert Andrew Pryor runs through the four main types of fly fishing flies: dry flies, wet flies, nymphs, and streamers.
Fly fishing flies can take all kinds of forms, shapes, and sizes. It is imperative to the fly fisher to know what you are trying to imitate when fly fishing to step into the mind of the fish you are targeting. There are so many categories and subcategories of different flies, but a majority of them fit into four major categories: Dry flies, wet flies, nymphs, and streamers.
Dry flies imitate a fly that has already hatched from its nymphal state, has wings, and is sitting on top of the water. The fish, likely a trout, will rise to the fly and sip it at the surface of the water. Typically these dry flies will be imitating aquatic insects that hatch from the water system, and will be most effective when the "hatch" is happening, or when the majority of these insects are transforming from their nymphal stage into the winged adult stage. This can be seen frequently with mayflies, stoneflies, caddisflies and even others like crane flies and midges.
When the dry fly in question isn't imitating an aquatic adult insect, the fly will be referred to as a terrestrial fly. These typically are better fished at the banks and resemble terrestrial insects, such as grasshoppers, beetles, ants, etc. These flies at the surface will be dead drifted to imitate a compromised fly on the water and are rarely supposed to be moved unless you are specifically fishing a skated fly or are using other surface strategies.
Wet flies are fished below the surface. They typically imitate flies that have been swept below the surface. Some flies even penetrate the water's surface to lay eggs. Wet flies have a strong hold in the classical roots of fishing with artificial flies and have many classical recipes and fly patterns used. Wet flies are typically swung across a stream or section of current with a tight line.This can be done with a floating or sinking fly line.
Spey flies are fished in a similar swinging motion but are a member of their own category due to the rod properly being a two-handed, much larger rod used to cover more water and the targeted fish typically being a salmon or steelhead.
Streamer flies, unlike wet flies, will imitate a smaller fish or a minnow fish. When fishing for trout, a sculpin pattern streamer or woolly bugger is a popular and typically productive choice. Streamers are a versatile type of fly due to the number of fish that will consume a smaller fish, which is what this type of fly can imitate in all kinds of situations. These flies will be "stripped" in, or pulled back in in a darting motion. Occasionally, this darting motion is applied to surface flies, like poppers or mice, which are in a category of their own.
Nymphs imitate the nymphal stage of aquatic insects. Like dry flies, they can become more active during their proper hatching period. The flies coincide with the same species of aquatic insects you'll use when fishing dry flies. A dead-drifted nymph fly is preferred, but the flies will be sub surface. Typically, fly anglers will choose to use strike indicators above the flies on the line to visibly see a strike from the fish. This can vary by strategy, though. Some euro-nymphers prefer to use a longer fly rod and no indicator. Nymphing for trout is a very productive way to catch, as most of a trout’s food is consumed below the surface.
Choosing the Right Fly
Choosing the right fly can be challenging, but with experience and knowledge, the fly fisher will be able to observe the stream and key into the mind of the trout. If a visible hatch caddis is coming off of the water, it would be a great choice to use the imitative pattern, the Elk Hair Caddis, for example. If this isn't doing the trick, different sizes and colors of Elk Hair Caddis should be used. If a hatch of mayflies is due, but not actively causing trout to rise to the surface, perhaps the Pheasant Tail pattern imitating a mayfly nymph would produce fish.
Casting a Fly
When casting a fly that is meant to be dead drifted down, it is a good move to stand downstream of your target fish, and cast upstream. The dry fly or nymph can then be drifted back down to you imitating a compromised aquatic insect. If the fly you want to fish is a wet fly, I would recommend a cast downstream. This will keep your line tight and apt to feeling a hit from a fish. Similarly, streamers are great to fish downstream, but also do really well when fished across the stream, from one bank to the other, and when fished in slack water.
It is hard to say if there is any one best way to target trout. Heading to your local fly shop or studying a hatch chart is always a good way to stock your fly box and get prepared for the water in your area. Fly fishing can take place year-round, if your local laws allow. Winter fishing can be a bit slower, but can really shine in the subsurface nymph category. Summer will provide all kinds of opportunities to cast a dry fly, terrestrial (land-based insect), and even a mouse for trout as they become more active and insects become more abundant.
Fly tying is a great way to save money and stay in tune with the system you are fishing. A good place to start fly tying is to head down to the stream you'll be fishing and flip a few rocks over to study the insects that are present. Once you discover the insects that you'll be imitating, you can find the appropriate patterns to match.
To make a fly, you'll need a vice for holding hooks, bobbin for holding thread, whip finisher for knots, thread, scissors, hooks, and the appropriate materials. There are tons of kits available out there to get started. These kits will provide bits of supplies but not in large quantities. If you are ready to make this a life-long skill, buying supplies on their own may be a good option and will get you more supplies for your dollar. Size, color, and shape are all critical things to consider when imitating a particular insect. A proper body taper on your fly, imitating a realistic nymph, is important to keep in mind when tying for the first time. The feeling you have when a fly that you’ve made is hit is truly unrivaled.
All things considered, fly fishing and choosing your fly can be very rewarding. All it really takes is a bit of studying and thinking like a trout.
If you have any questions about finding the right fly for your next adventure, please feel free to reach out to me or one of my fellow Fly Fishing experts here at Curated.