The Top 7 Most Recommended Casserole Dishes

Published on 10/13/2023 · 7 min readLooking to expand your cookware collection and try some new recipes? Check out the top 7 recommended casserole dishes that can help you make some delicious, new meals!
Shelby Owens, Kitchen Expert
By Kitchen Expert Shelby Owens

Photo by P Maxwell Photography

When you think of casserole dishes, you think of… casserole. But there is so much more to these kitchen staples than Mom’s chicken casserole. I think of bread pudding, pasta, sweet potatoes, pot roast, and so much more! If you’ve found this article, you know that not every dish is created equal. That’s why I’ve rounded up the best dishes on the market to help you make this life-or-death decision (sorry for being dramatic).

Why Invest in Quality Casserole Dishes?

Before we dive into the recommended products, let's chat about why investing in quality casserole dishes can totally elevate your cooking game. Here are their best advantages:

Versatility

As I said before, casserole dishes are not limited to baking casseroles alone. They can be used for roasting, braising, simmering, and, of course, serving your favorite dishes. A high-quality casserole dish is stovetop and oven-safe for easy transition.

Even Heat Distribution

Quality casserole dishes are designed to distribute heat evenly, ensuring that your dishes cook consistently without hot spots. What happens when you use your aluminum deep dish? Inconsistent baking and scattered burns on your dish. Most of the time, if I'm using a bad baking dish, I can’t tell it’s burnt until I serve it, which is always an epic fail. So, another great reason to go for a quality casserole dish all the way.

Durability

Investing in a well-made casserole dish means you'll have a kitchen companion that can withstand years of use. Unlike aluminum pans that discolor in a few uses, your casserole dish made of stone, stainless steel, or cast iron will definitely stand the test of time. There is no cracking, discoloration, or warping to worry about when you choose a quality material and manufacturer.

Aesthetic Appeal

Let's not forget the visual appeal of a beautifully designed casserole dish. Many of the options we'll explore not only bake well but also add a touch of elegance to your kitchen and dining table.

Top Casserole Dishes

Now that we've gone over the big-seller highlights of quality casserole dishes let's get into reviewing the best casserole dishes:

1. Le Creuset Heritage Covered 4-qt Rectangular Casserole

The Le Creuset Heritage Covered 4-qt Rectangular Casserole. Photo courtesy of Le Creuset

Let's kick things off with some classic bakeware: the Le Creuset Heritage Covered 4-qt Rectangular Casserole. Le Creuset has been around for a long time, helping home chefs get quality results out of their recipes, and this casserole dish is no exception.

Pros:

  • Timeless design and available in various colors to match your kitchen decor.
  • Made from durable stoneware that distributes heat evenly.
  • Tight-fitting lid keeps moisture and flavor locked in.
  • Oven-safe, microwave-safe, freezer-safe, and broiler-safe.
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe.
  • Perfect for storing leftovers.

Cons:

  • Premium price.
  • Heavy compared to some other options.

2. Hestan Provisions 9" x 13" OvenBond Rectangular Baker

The Hestan Provisions 9" x 13" OvenBond Rectangular Baker. Photo courtesy of Hestan

Spotted: stainless steel. The Hestan Provisions 9" x 13" OvenBond Rectangular Baker is made in California and has all the perks we talked about to make your baking more consistent. And as far as stainless steel goes, this dish still brings a great aesthetic to the final product.

Pros:

  • Exceptional heat retention and even cooking.
  • Metal utensil-safe due to its titanium-infused nonstick surface.
  • Easy food release for quick and effortless cleanup.
  • Stylish design with a sleek stainless steel handle.
  • Can go from the oven to the table for a beautiful presentation.

Cons:

  • Higher price point.
  • Nonstick surface may require extra care to maintain.

3. Ruffoni Historia 12.5" Open Rectangular Gratin

The Ruffoni Historia 12.5" Open Rectangular Gratin. Photo courtesy of Ruffoni

This dish looks like it came straight out of Downton Abbey (and here, that’s a good thing). For those who appreciate good presentation plus quality craftsmanship, the Ruffoni Historia 12.5" Open Rectangular Gratin is for you,

Pros:

  • Hand-hammered copper exterior adds a touch of luxury to your kitchen.
  • Excellent heat conductivity for precise cooking.
  • Stainless steel interior for easy cleaning.
  • Beautiful brass handles for a sophisticated look.
  • Ideal for both cooking and serving dishes.

Cons:

  • Premium price reflects the artisanal craftsmanship.
  • Copper may require special maintenance to keep its shine.

4. Cuisinart Round Covered Casserole

For our flavor-obsessed readers, enameled cast iron is the way to go. After every bake, the quality of flavor for every dish just gets better and better. But remember, never cook acidic foods or foods like eggs or fish that can cause odors in iron casserole dishes. Those are flavors you don’t want lingering around for the next bake. This Cuisinart cast iron casserole dish is perfect for a chicken pot pie, a crispy cobbler, baked mac and cheese, and so much more.

Pros:

  • Affordable option for those on a budget.
  • Made from cast iron for excellent heat retention and even cooking.
  • Durable porcelain enamel exterior is resistant to chipping and cracking.
  • Versatile and suitable for various cooking methods.
  • Available in multiple colors to match your kitchen decor.

Cons:

  • Heavyweight, which may be cumbersome for some users.
  • Specific washing instructions to care for cast iron dishes; soap is not recommended.
  • Very hot water is needed when hand-washing.

5. Viking Professional 5-Ply 3.4 QT, 3.1 L Casserole Pan, Satin Finish

The Viking Professional 5-Ply Casserole Pan. Photo courtesy of Viking

Five. Steel. Layers. What does this mean for your next recipe? Even cooking every time. The more layers, the more heat spreads evenly. So, even if you have an oven that bakes unevenly, this dish will be your saving grace. Plus, the steel brush finish? Now that will add the perfect look to your kitchen. The Viking Professional 5-Ply Casserole Pan offers a balance of performance and elegance that's sure to impress any cook.

Pros:

  • Five-ply construction ensures even heating and precise temperature control.
  • Compatible with all cooktops, including induction.
  • Large capacity makes it suitable for preparing family-sized meals.
  • Ergonomic handles provide a secure and comfortable grip.
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe.

Cons:

  • Slightly higher price point.
  • Heavier compared to some alternatives.

6. KitchenAid 3-Ply Base Stainless Steel Induction Casserole with Lid

The KitchenAid 3-Ply Base Stainless Steel Induction Casserole. Photo courtesy of KitchenAid

Just like the picture, this pot makes pot roast perfection. When you need to put a good sear on meat using the stovetop and then slow-roast it in the oven, this is the perfect solution. From oven to stove, serve, and repeat. The KitchenAid 3-Ply Base Stainless Steel Induction Casserole continues to impress home chefs with its practicality and performance.

Pros:

  • Durable stainless steel construction with an aluminum core for even heating.
  • Compatible with induction cooktops and all other stovetops.
  • Transparent glass lid lets you monitor cooking without lifting the cover.
  • Dishwasher-safe for hassle-free cleanup.
  • Reasonably priced for the quality.

Cons:

  • Stainless steel may require additional care to prevent discoloration.

7. Circulon Symmetry Hard-Anodized Nonstick 5.5-Quart Casserole with Lid

The Circulon’s Symmetry Hard-Anodized Nonstick Casserole. Photo courtesy of Circulon

I have to throw in a nonstick option out there! And of them all, Circulon’s Symmetry Hard-Anodized Nonstick Casserole takes the cake. It’s a practical choice for those who appreciate the convenience of nonstick cookware. Easy cleanup, no scrubbing or scraping, just serve, rinse, and go.

Pros:

  • Hard-anodized aluminum construction for fast and even heating.
  • Nonstick interior ensures easy food release and quick cleanup.
  • Shatter-resistant glass lid with a wide handle for easy lifting.
  • Suitable for all stovetops, including induction.
  • Affordable price for a nonstick casserole.

Cons:

  • Nonstick surface may require replacement over time.
  • Limited color options compared to other brands.

Find Your Perfect Match

Photo by Timolina

Choosing the right casserole dish set depends on your cooking style, preferences, and budget. If you're still unsure which casserole dish suits your needs best, don't hesitate to reach out to a Curated Kitchen Expert. They can provide free, personalized recommendations to make sure your next casserole dish is a perfect match for your kitchen adventures. So, go ahead and upgrade your cookware collection, and start crafting delicious dishes that will leave your friends and fam impressed!

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Kitchen on Curated

Le Creuset Heritage Rectangular Casserole · 4 QT
$135.00
Hestan Provisions OvenBond Tri-ply Rectangular Baker
$110.00
Ruffoni Historia Rectangular Roaster · 12.5 Inch
$320.00

Browse more Kitchen

Viking Professional 5-Ply Stainless Steel Casserole Pan
$249.99$349.99
KitchenAid Stainless Steel Casserole with Lid · 4 QT
$69.99
Circulon Symmetry Nonstick Casserole · 5.5 QT
$79.99
Viking Professional 5-Ply Stainless Steel Casserole Pan
$419.99
Le Creuset Heritage Rectangular Casserole · 4 QT
$135.00

Read next

New and Noteworthy