Expert Comparison: Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons
VS
In this comparison, we are looking at two of Callaway's top-tier iron sets: the 2023 Big Bertha Irons and the Rogue ST Pro Irons. Both sets are designed with advanced technology to enhance performance, but they cater to different types of golfers. The Big Bertha Irons are known for their exceptional forgiveness and easy-to-hit design, making them ideal for players seeking improved launch and control. On the other hand, the Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed for mid-handicap players who need distance and the ability to work the ball. They offer a blend of forgiveness and workability, making them a great choice for players looking to improve their game. The final verdict will depend on the specific needs and skill level of the golfer.
Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons summary
The Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons are designed with precision tungsten weighting and an A.I. designed face cup. These features contribute to improved launch, control, and fast ball speeds. The irons are also known for their lightweight components and confidence-inspiring Bertha shape, making them easy to swing with an outstanding feel. The Black Smoke finish adds a premium look to the set.
These irons feature a titanium face and core, which is usually reserved for drivers. This design choice saves a significant amount of weight, making the irons extremely easy to hit. The high-strength, lightweight titanium face is paired with 145g of tungsten in the irons, a 100% increase from the Rogue ST max line. This combination results in one of the most forgiving and powerful irons Callaway has ever designed.
However, these irons may not be the best fit for advanced, high-speed players who prefer a more refined "players" set. They are also not ideal for low handicappers. But for players with slower swing speeds, the Big Bertha Irons offer a great combination of power, forgiveness, and good turf interaction.
The New big bertha irons for 2023. These feature a titanium face and core. Usually, Titanium is reserved for drivers but this saves a ton of weight and makes these irons super easy to hit. High strength but so so very light. Forged titanium face. 145g of tungsten in these irons which is 100% increase from the Rogue ST max line. These will be one of the most forgiving and powerful irons Callaway has ever designed.
The New big bertha irons for 2023. These feature a titanium face and core. Usually, Titanium is reserved for drivers but this saves a ton of weight and makes these irons super easy to hit. High strength but so so very light. Forged titanium face. 145g of tungsten in these irons which is 100% increase from the Rogue ST max line. These will be one of the most forgiving and powerful irons Callaway has ever designed.
Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons summary
The Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed for mid-handicap players who need distance and the ability to work the ball. They offer a blend of forgiveness and workability, making them a great choice for players looking to improve their game. The irons feature extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance. The new face technology provides a good overall feel coming off the face.
The Rogue ST Pro irons have a blade-type look, but they offer a thick top line for confidence and some offset that doesn't make the player feel like they are playing with a butter knife. The irons have a strong loft to aid in distance, but the weighting in the clubs still launches the ball very nicely. The irons are also surprisingly forgiving for a mid-handicapper club.
However, the feel of the club was lacking; there is not a very soft face or feeling at impact. The sound was a very muted, more solid sound and not that crispy click of a pure strike. The thick top line at address may not be appealing to some players.
Overall, I recommend these irons for any player needing some extra distance without sacrificing the ability to work the ball. They have the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club; to me, this is the best combo for the mid-handicap golfer.
Overall, I recommend these irons for any player needing some extra distance without sacrificing the ability to work the ball. They have the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club; to me, this is the best combo for the mid-handicap golfer.
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Similarities
Both the Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons and the Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed with advanced technology to enhance performance on the golf course. They both feature precision tungsten weighting for improved launch and control, and they both have a focus on delivering fast ball speeds. Both sets of irons are designed to be easy to hit, with features that inspire confidence in the player. They also both have a premium look, with the Big Bertha Irons featuring a Black Smoke finish and the Rogue ST Pro Irons having a sleek, blade-type look.
Differences and Who They're Good For
While there are similarities between the two sets of irons, there are also key differences that make each set suitable for different types of golfers. The Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons are designed for players looking for an easy-to-hit iron with exceptional forgiveness. They are particularly suitable for players with slower swing speeds who need help launching the ball down the fairways and onto the green.
On the other hand, the Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed for mid-handicap players who need distance and the ability to work the ball. They offer a blend of forgiveness and workability, making them a great choice for players looking to improve their game. These irons are particularly suitable for players who want a club that looks like a “players” club but offers the distance and forgiveness of a game improvement club.
Analysis on Who’s the Winner
Forgiveness: The Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons take the win in this category. They are designed with exceptional forgiveness, making them ideal for players who need help with their swing.
Distance: The Rogue ST Pro Irons win in the distance category. They are designed with extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance.
Workability: The Rogue ST Pro Irons also take the win in this category. They offer the ability to work the ball, which is a key feature for mid-handicap players looking to improve their game.
Aesthetics: This category is subjective and depends on the player's personal preference. The Big Bertha Irons feature a Black Smoke finish for a premium look, while the Rogue ST Pro Irons have a sleek, blade-type look.
Comparison Table
Side by side comparison | | Runner up |
|---|---|---|
Price | from:$600.00 22% off | from:$771.42 25% off |
User rating | 4.95(22) | 4.96(57) |
The Curated Take | Best for golfers seeking forgiveness and power in their irons. | Best for low to mid-handicap golfers seeking workability and forgiveness. |
Iron Set Type | Iron Set | Iron Set |
Player type | Game improvement | Players distance |
Used (Y/N) | No | No |
Conclusions
In conclusion, both the Callaway 2023 Big Bertha Irons and the Rogue ST Pro Irons are top-tier iron sets designed with advanced technology to enhance performance on the golf course. The right set for you will depend on your specific needs and skill level. If you're looking for an easy-to-hit iron with exceptional forgiveness, the Big Bertha Irons would be a great choice. However, if you're a mid-handicap player who needs distance and the ability to work the ball, the Rogue ST Pro Irons would be a better fit. Ultimately, both sets offer a blend of performance-enhancing features that can help you improve your game.
