Expert Comparison: Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls vs 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants

Published on 02/12/2024 · 4 min readCompare Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls and 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants. Get expert insight below!
Josh Kulchin, Snowboarding Expert
Michele J., Snowboarding Expert
Alex Dolan, Snowboarding Expert
Contributed By Snowboarding Expert Josh Kulchin, Michele J., Alex Dolan, Zach Hargreaves, Taylor OShea and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Out of stock
Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls
686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants
Price
from:$149.95
42% off
from:$202.97
30% off
Color options
+ 1
User rating
5(1)
--
The Curated Take
--

Best for all-season skiers needing durable, versatile and waterproof pants.

Features
Bib, Waterproof, Hand-warmer pockets, Breathable
Waterproof, Windproof, Belt loop
Insulation type
None
None

In the world of winter sports, the right gear can make or break your experience. Today, we're comparing two top-notch products: the Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls and the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants. Both are excellent choices, but they cater to different needs and preferences. The Volcom Roan Bib Overalls are praised for their environmental friendliness, comfort, and excellent coverage. On the other hand, the 686 SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants are lauded for their versatility, durability, and impressive waterproofing. While both products have their strengths, the choice between the two ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences.

The Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls are a fantastic choice for those seeking comprehensive coverage. These overalls boast a waterproof and breathable rating of 15,000mm / 15,000gm, making them ideal for keeping you dry and comfortable in various weather conditions. The V-science shell, made with REPREVE® recycled fibers and non-fluorinated DWR, reduces environmental impact while providing excellent protection against the elements. The relaxed fit, adjustable elastic suspenders, and neoprene jersey at side waists ensure a comfortable and customizable fit. The fully-taped seams and Zip Tech® jacket-to-pant interface offer top-to-toe coverage with the mobility of pants. These overalls are perfect for those who want the coverage of a onesie with the flexibility of pants.

The Roan Bib is the real hookup when it comes to coverage. 15Ks of breathable waterproofing comes in a 2-layer V-science shell made with REPREVE® recycled fibers and non-fluorinated DWR for less of an impact on the environment and a big impact on the elements.

Josh Kulchin
Snowboarding Expert

The 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants are a versatile and durable option for all-season skiers. These bib pants feature a removable stretch fleece liner for extra warmth on cold days, and the shell is made with 20K waterproof fabric to keep you dry in any conditions. The external waist adjusters, anti-abrasion coated kick panels, and fully taped seams make these pants built to last. The bib design prevents ride-up, and the multiple pockets add convenience. Whether you're hitting the slopes or hanging out après ski, the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants have the performance and durability you need.

Backed by impressive 20K/20K waterproof breathability, these storm-ready bibs feature a removable stretch-poly fleece pant midlayer that can be worn like sweatpants during après activities. Sprinkle in fully taped Bemis® seams, burly 500-denier hems and kick panels, and reinforced seam stitching throughout, the 686 Smarty 3-in-1 Cargo Bibs have both the performance and durability needed to live out your mountain man, hardcore snowboarder/skier life. Now that's smart.

Michele J.
Snowboarding Expert

Similarities

Both the Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls and the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants are designed with the winter sports enthusiast in mind. They both offer excellent waterproofing and breathability, ensuring you stay dry and comfortable on the slopes. Both products also feature adjustable elements for a customizable fit, and they both have fully-taped seams for added durability. Additionally, both bibs offer top-to-toe coverage, providing excellent protection against the elements.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both products are excellent choices, they cater to different needs and preferences. The Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls are perfect for those who prioritize environmental sustainability, as they are made with recycled fibers. They are also ideal for those who prefer a relaxed fit and the coverage of a onesie with the mobility of pants.

On the other hand, the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants are perfect for all-season skiers who need a versatile and durable pant. The removable fleece liner allows for adaptability in different weather conditions, and the 20K waterproof fabric ensures you stay dry in any conditions. These pants are also great for those who prefer a cargo style and need multiple pockets for convenience.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

When it comes to environmental sustainability, the Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls take the lead with their use of recycled fibers. For versatility, the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants come out on top with their removable fleece liner. In terms of waterproofing, the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants have a higher rating, making them the winner in this category. However, for comfort and fit, both products are on par, offering adjustable elements for a customizable fit.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls and the 686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants are excellent choices for winter sports enthusiasts. The Volcom bibs are a great choice for those who prioritize environmental sustainability and prefer a relaxed fit, while the 686 bibs are perfect for all-season skiers who need versatility and durability. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on your specific needs and preferences. So, whether you're a seasoned pro or a beginner on the slopes, both of these products offer top-notch features that will enhance your winter sports experience.

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Winter Sports on Curated

Volcom Men's Roan Bib Overalls
$149.95$260.00
686 Men's SMARTY 3-in-1 Cargo Bib Pants
$202.97$289.95
Marker Griffon 13 ID Ski Bindings · 2024
$269.99

Browse more Winter Sports

CAPiTA Defenders of Awesome Snowboard · 2024
$384.97$549.95
Burton Step On Re:Flex Snowboard Bindings · 2024
$299.95
K2 Mindbender 90C Skis · 2024
$299.97$499.95
Flow Fenix Snowboard Bindings · 2024
$143.97$239.95
Salomon Sleepwalker Snowboard · 2024
$279.97$399.95

Browse more Winter Sports

Read next

New and Noteworthy