Expert Comparison: Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter vs Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter

Published on 02/01/2024 · 5 min readCompare Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter and Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter. Get expert insight below!
Gavin Nickerson, Golf Expert
David L. Brown, Golf Expert
Andrew Abbott, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert Gavin Nickerson, David L. Brown, Andrew Abbott, Christopher Colburn, Jordan Daane and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Out of stock
Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter
Most recommended
Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter
Price
$399.99
$429.99
User rating
5(2)
5(2)
The Curated Take

Best for players who prioritize feel and consistent roll on all green speeds/grasses.

Best for serious golfers seeking improved precision, stability, and alignment.

Head shape
#2
#5.5
Neck hosel shape
Plumber's Neck
Small Slant
Club Type
Putters
Putters

In the world of golf, the putter is a crucial piece of equipment that can make or break your game. Today, we're comparing two top-tier putters from the renowned Scotty Cameron line by Titleist: the Special Select Newport 2 and the Phantom X 5.5. Both putters are praised for their exceptional performance, feel, and design, but they cater to different types of golfers and strokes. The Newport 2 is a classic blade putter that offers a traditional look and feel, while the Phantom X 5.5 is a mallet putter that provides enhanced stability and alignment. Both putters are high-end and come with a hefty price tag, but they're worth the investment if you're serious about improving your game. The Newport 2 is ideal for mid-handicappers who love the look and feel of a blade putter, while the Phantom X 5.5 is perfect for golfers who prefer a mallet putter with a slight arc in their stroke. In the end, the choice between these two putters comes down to personal preference and playing style.

The Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter is a classic blade putter that combines a timeless look with top-notch performance. This putter is known for its solid feel, responsive face, and excellent weight distribution. It's designed with a mid-milled face pattern, a flatter, narrower topline, and a redesigned plumber neck for improved visibility and ease of alignment. The putter also features performance-balanced tungsten sole weights for a larger sweet spot and enhanced stability. The Newport 2 is beautifully weighted, allowing golfers to focus on controlled strokes without having to slam long putts. The aesthetic appeal of this putter is undeniable, with a sleek black finish that takes the look to the next level. However, it's worth noting that this putter is not the most forgiving, especially on mishits. The standard Scotty Cameron grip may not be for everyone, as some golfers find it a bit too soft and lacking in thicker options. Despite these minor issues, the Newport 2 is a high-quality putter that holds its value well and can truly unlock your full putting potential.

The best thing about the Scotty Cameron Newport 2 is they haven’t tinkered too much with design or material. Even the 2016 model has almost all of the same features as the newer ones, and that is one of the reasons why their resale value is so high.

Gavin Nickerson
Golf Expert

The Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter is a mallet putter that offers exceptional precision, stability, and alignment features. This putter is designed with a solid milled 303 stainless steel face that provides a soft feel and consistent sound at impact. The high-MOI design enhances stability throughout the stroke, reducing twisting and improving forgiveness. The Phantom X 5.5 also incorporates visual alignment aids to assist with proper setup and alignment, promoting improved accuracy and confidence on the greens. The putter's weight is perfectly suited for keeping the club down and through each putt, and it feels effortless to swing the putter back and through. The aesthetic appeal of this putter is also top-notch, with a sleek silver finish and a distinct wing design. However, the high price point may be a potential drawback for some golfers.

The Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 is the premier putter on the market. It has a milled face design that allows for one of the easiest most comfortable putter swings I have ever felt. I didn't miss more than 3 out of 20 some putts from within 8 feet.

David L. Brown
Golf Expert

Similarities

Both the Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 and the Phantom X 5.5 putters are high-end products that offer exceptional performance, feel, and design. They are both crafted with meticulous attention to detail, reflecting the quality associated with the Scotty Cameron brand. Both putters feature a milled face for a soft feel and consistent sound at impact, and they both offer excellent weight distribution for a smooth and controlled stroke. Both putters also have visual alignment aids to assist with proper setup and alignment, and they both have a high resale value due to their quality and reputation.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both putters are top-tier, they cater to different types of golfers and strokes. The Newport 2 is a blade putter that offers a traditional look and feel. It's ideal for mid-handicappers who love the look and feel of a blade putter and have a straight up straight through stroke. On the other hand, the Phantom X 5.5 is a mallet putter that provides enhanced stability and alignment. It's perfect for golfers who prefer a mallet putter with a slight arc in their stroke. The Newport 2 has a sleek black finish, while the Phantom X 5.5 has a sleek silver finish. The Newport 2 also has a plumber neck, while the Phantom X 5.5 has a single bend neck. In terms of price, both putters are on the higher end, but the Phantom X 5.5 is slightly more expensive.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

When it comes to design, the Newport 2 wins for its classic blade look and sleek black finish. For feel and performance, it's a tie, as both putters offer a soft feel, excellent weight distribution, and consistent sound at impact. In terms of alignment, the Phantom X 5.5 takes the lead with its enhanced visual alignment aids. Lastly, for value for money, the Newport 2 wins as it offers similar performance and quality at a slightly lower price point.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 and the Phantom X 5.5 putters are top-tier products that offer exceptional performance, feel, and design. They cater to different types of golfers and strokes, with the Newport 2 being ideal for mid-handicappers who love the look and feel of a blade putter, and the Phantom X 5.5 being perfect for golfers who prefer a mallet putter with a slight arc in their stroke. Both putters are high-end and come with a hefty price tag, but they're worth the investment if you're serious about improving your game. In the end, the choice between these two putters comes down to personal preference and playing style. So, whether you're a fan of the classic blade look or prefer the enhanced stability of a mallet putter, you can't go wrong with either of these Scotty Cameron putters.

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter
$399.99
Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5 Putter
$429.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$599.94$857.16

Browse more Golf

Callaway XR Packaged Complete Golf Set
$1,399.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$799.92$1,142.88
Callaway Mavrik Irons
$799.95$1,028.56
TaylorMade Stealth Irons
$899.99$1,099.99
Cobra LTDx MAX Driver
$199.99$499.00
Cobra FLY-XL Complete Set
$899.00
Callaway Paradym AI Smoke Irons
$1,257.12

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy