Expert Comparison: Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
VS
Side by side comparison |  Runner up |  Runner up |
|---|---|---|
Price | from:$771.42 25% off | from:$499.95 30% off |
User rating | 4.96(57) | 4.84(175) |
The Curated Take | Best for low to mid-handicap golfers seeking workability and forgiveness. | Best for mid to high-handicap golfers seeking increased distance and forgiveness. |
Iron Set Type | Iron Set | Iron Set |
Player type | Players distance | Game improvement |
Used (Y/N) | No | No |
In the world of golf, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are two top-tier products that have been making waves. Both irons are designed with advanced technology and features that cater to different types of golfers. The Rogue ST Pro Irons are perfect for mid-handicap golfers who need extra distance and the ability to work the ball, while the Rogue ST Max Irons are ideal for golfers seeking forgiveness, speed, and all-around performance. Both irons utilize Artificial Intelligence in their design for optimized speed, launch, and spin, and tungsten weighting for optimal launch. However, the Rogue ST Pro Irons have a more compact, workable shape and a hollow body construction, while the Rogue ST Max Irons have a refined game improvement shaping and strong lofts. In the end, the choice between the two depends on the golfer's skill level, playing style, and personal preferences.
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons summary
The Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are a mid-handicap distance iron that boasts extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance. The new face technology is a standout feature, providing a good overall feel coming off the face. This club is perfect for those needing some distance and a club where one can feel comfortable working the ball.
The model tested was a 7 iron with a loft of 30.5, fitted with a True Temper Elevate MPH 115 shaft in X-stiff flex. The club was tested in sunny conditions at the Shingle Creek Golf Academy in Orlando, Florida, using a Titleist Pro V1 golf ball.
The Rogue ST Pro Irons have a blade-type look but offer a thick top line for confidence and some offset that doesn't make the golfer feel like they are playing with a butter knife. The club is surprisingly forgiving for a mid-handicapper, with 48 grams of tungsten weighting keeping the spin low to moderate, making it difficult to hit the ball largely off line. The club also offers high workability, a feature not usually found in a mid-handicapper club.
However, the club does have some issues. The feel of the club was lacking, with a muted feel at impact that didn't provide feedback on whether the shot was hit in the center of the face, heel, or toe. The sound was also a muted, solid sound, not the crispy click of a pure strike. The thick top line at address may not be to everyone's liking, and the iron is a medium to low-spinning iron.
Despite these issues, the Rogue ST Pro Irons are recommended for any player needing some extra distance without sacrificing the ability to work the ball. They offer the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club, making them a great choice for mid-handicap golfers.
I really think Callaway has a secret weapon in the Rogue ST Pro iron, and I feel that this club should be in the majority of mid-handicappers’ golf bags.
I really think Callaway has a secret weapon in the Rogue ST Pro iron, and I feel that this club should be in the majority of mid-handicappers’ golf bags.
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons summary
The Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are a game improvement iron that offers a high level of forgiveness and distance. They feature a traditional hollow back design and a major upgrade from the previous Mavrik Series. The irons offer more distance and higher launch with a thinner sole. The AI-designed Flash Face Cup and tungsten weighting help create a stable club head that results in straight shots, healthy launch angles, and a feeling that it is just an easy club to hit.
The Rogue ST Max Irons have a lot of offset, a thick top line, and a large overall head size, making them a super game-improvement iron. They are designed with a high-strength 450 steel with an AI flash faced cup face for more ball speed and consistency. The high launch with a more controlled landing angle helps to hold more greens. The precision tungsten weighting for optimal launch and the urethane microspheres for improved feel while maintaining fast ball speeds make these irons a great choice for mid- to high-handicap golfers seeking distance and forgiveness.
However, the Rogue ST Max Irons are not suitable for low handicaps and are not ideal for shaping shots. They are also not suitable for beginners or slicers who struggle to get the ball in the air and those with slower swing speeds.
These clubs are rockets, they effortlessly launch the ball high and far. They are a little bulkier when looking down at them from the top. In the simulator, I was about 12 yards longer in these irons than my current irons.
These clubs are rockets, they effortlessly launch the ball high and far. They are a little bulkier when looking down at them from the top. In the simulator, I was about 12 yards longer in these irons than my current irons.
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Similarities
Both the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are designed with advanced technology to optimize speed, launch, and spin. They both utilize Artificial Intelligence in their design and feature tungsten weighting for optimal launch. Both irons are designed to increase distance and offer a high level of forgiveness, making them suitable for a wide range of golfers. They both also feature urethane microspheres for enhanced feel and sound while maintaining fast ball speeds.
Differences and Who They're Good For
While both irons offer similar features, they cater to different types of golfers. The Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed for mid-handicap golfers who need extra distance and the ability to work the ball. They have a more compact, workable shape and a hollow body construction, making them a great choice for golfers who want the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club.
On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are a game improvement iron that offers a high level of forgiveness and distance. They have a refined game improvement shaping and strong lofts, making them ideal for golfers seeking forgiveness, speed, and all-around performance. They are not suitable for low handicaps and are not ideal for shaping shots.
Analysis on Who’s the Winner
When it comes to distance, both irons perform exceptionally well. However, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons have a slight edge due to their stronger lofts and hot face, which result in significant distance gains.
In terms of forgiveness, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are the clear winner. They are designed as a super game-improvement iron with a lot of offset, a thick top line, and a large overall head size, making them very forgiving.
For workability, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons take the lead. They offer the workability of a high-end players club, allowing golfers to shape their shots more effectively.
Lastly, in terms of feel and sound, both irons offer enhanced feel and sound due to the urethane microspheres. However, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons may have a slight advantage due to their hollow body construction.
Conclusions
In conclusion, both the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons are top-tier products that cater to different types of golfers. The Rogue ST Pro Irons are perfect for mid-handicap golfers who need extra distance and the ability to work the ball, while the Rogue ST Max Irons are ideal for golfers seeking forgiveness, speed, and all-around performance. Both irons utilize Artificial Intelligence in their design for optimized speed, launch, and spin, and tungsten weighting for optimal launch. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the golfer's skill level, playing style, and personal preferences. So, whether you're a mid-handicap golfer looking to work the ball or a golfer seeking forgiveness and speed, Callaway has got you covered!
