Expert Comparison: Wilson D9 Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons

Published on 02/09/2024 · 6 min readCompare Wilson D9 Irons and Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons. Get expert insight below!
David L. Brown, Golf Expert
Ari T, Golf Expert
Jonathan Belanger, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert David L. Brown, Ari T, Jonathan Belanger, Michael V, Laura Kinsman and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Out of stock
Wilson D9 Irons
Runner up
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
Price
from:$399.99
47% off
from:$499.95
30% off
User rating
4.86(7)
4.87(83)
The Curated Take

Ideal for mid-high handicappers seeking distance and high launch

Best for beginners or golfers struggling with a consistent iron game due to its extreme forgiveness.

Iron Set Type
Iron Set
Iron Set
Player type
Game improvement
Super game improvement
Used (Y/N)
No
No

In the world of golf, the right set of irons can make a significant difference in your game. Today, we're comparing two top-notch iron sets: the Wilson D9 Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons. Both sets are designed with the mid to high-tiered handicapper in mind, offering a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel. However, they each have their unique strengths and weaknesses. The Wilson D9 Irons are praised for their forgiveness and sound, but they fall short in terms of distance and workability compared to other irons. On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are known for their larger club head, optimized launch, and increased ball speed, but they may not provide the desired level of control for players seeking a high level of shot customization. In the end, the choice between these two sets of irons will depend on your specific needs and preferences as a golfer.

The Wilson D9 Irons are a solid option for golfers looking to improve their mid-range game. These irons are designed with mid to high-tiered handicappers in mind, offering a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel. The clubs are equipped with a power sole and head design that ensures off-centered hits still travel a considerable distance and rarely deviate significantly from the target line. The sound of the clubs is simple and pleasing, avoiding the loud, ear-piercing ping that some golfers find off-putting.

The regular steel flex irons allow for solid, consistent contact, instilling confidence in golfers as their ball flight aligns with their expectations. The shaft performance is commendable, enabling consistent strikes and a consistent spin rate of around 7,500rpms. The launch angle is also impressive, with the ball flying off the face quickly and maintaining a relatively low trajectory, resulting in consistent ball flights.

However, the Wilson D9 Irons are not without their shortcomings. The distance they offer is comparable to older models like the TaylorMade Racs, but they fall short when compared to the Callaway Rogues and TaylorMade Stealths. The feel of the clubs is average at best, with the face not offering much feedback on mishits. The workability of the clubs is also basic, limiting the golfer's ability to move the ball from right to left.

The Wilson D9 Irons are great for the basic golfer looking to improve their game or would be great for someone just starting. However, I would look elsewhere at the TaylorMade Stealths or Callaway Rogue series for the more serious golfer.

David L. Brown
Golf Expert

The Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are another excellent option for mid to high-tiered handicappers. These irons are designed with a larger club head, providing a larger sweet spot and increased forgiveness. The offset design of the clubs helps golfers who struggle with slicing the ball, while the wider sole aids in making better contact, especially on shots hit behind the golf ball.

The Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons also feature a perimeter weighting system, with tungsten placed around the outside of the club to prevent twisting and ensure more consistent golf strikes. The clubs also feature a Flash Face Cup and high-strength steel, which increase ball speed and, consequently, distance.

The clubs also feature urethane microspheres, which give the Rogue STs a fantastic feel, something that is often lacking in game improvement clubs. However, these irons may not provide the desired level of control for players seeking a high level of shot customization.

This is one of the best sets out there for someone who wants a long and forgiving set that helps fight a slice. These have a lot of offset which helps fix a slice but can be bad for someone who moves it left naturally. Very solid feel when hit in the center. Very good performance on mishits. These are highly recommended for an easy-to-use set for the mid-to-high handicapper.

Ari T
Golf Expert
Best seller

Similarities

Both the Wilson D9 Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are designed with the mid to high-tiered handicapper in mind. They both offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel, making them ideal for golfers looking to improve their game. Both sets of irons feature a larger club head and a wider sole, which aids in making better contact, especially on shots hit behind the golf ball. They also both feature technologies that increase ball speed and, consequently, distance.

In terms of aesthetics, both sets of irons have a sleek, refined look that appeals to many golfers. They also both offer a fantastic feel, something that is often lacking in game improvement clubs.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While the Wilson D9 Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons share many similarities, they also have their unique strengths and weaknesses. The Wilson D9 Irons are praised for their forgiveness and sound, but they fall short in terms of distance and workability compared to other irons. These irons would be a great fit for golfers who prioritize forgiveness and are not overly concerned with maximizing distance or shaping their shots.

On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are known for their larger club head, optimized launch, and increased ball speed. However, they may not provide the desired level of control for players seeking a high level of shot customization. These irons would be a great fit for golfers who prioritize distance and forgiveness but are willing to sacrifice some control over their shot shape and trajectory.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

When comparing the Wilson D9 Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons, the winner in each dimension depends on the specific needs and preferences of the golfer.

  1. Forgiveness: Both sets of irons offer a high level of forgiveness, but the Wilson D9 Irons are particularly praised for their forgiveness. Winner: Wilson D9 Irons.
  2. Distance: The Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons have the edge in terms of distance, thanks to their Flash Face Cup and high-strength steel. Winner: Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons.
  3. Feel: Both sets of irons offer a fantastic feel, but the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are noted for their increased urethane microspheres, which give them a slight edge. Winner: Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons.
  4. Workability: Neither set of irons is particularly known for their workability, but the Wilson D9 Irons are noted for their limited ability to shape shots. Winner: Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the Wilson D9 Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are excellent options for mid to high-tiered handicappers looking to improve their game. The Wilson D9 Irons offer a high level of forgiveness and a pleasing sound, making them a great choice for golfers who prioritize these features. However, they fall short in terms of distance and workability compared to other irons.

On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons offer a larger club head, optimized launch, and increased ball speed, making them a great choice for golfers who prioritize distance and forgiveness. However, they may not provide the desired level of control for players seeking a high level of shot customization.

In the end, the choice between these two sets of irons will depend on your specific needs and preferences as a golfer. So, whether you're a "forgiveness-first" kind of golfer or a "distance-demon," there's an iron set out there that's perfect for you. Happy golfing!

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

Wilson D9 Irons
$399.99$599.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$499.95$714.30
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$914.24$1,257.12

Browse more Golf

Callaway Mavrik Irons
$599.99$799.99
TaylorMade Stealth Irons
$914.28$1,142.85
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$914.24$1,257.12
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$799.92$1,028.56
Callaway Paradym AI Smoke Irons
$999.99
TaylorMade Stealth 2 HD Combo Set
$799.99$1,399.99
Wilson D9 Irons
$399.99$749.99

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy