Expert Comparison: TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons

Published on 02/09/2024 · 6 min readCompare TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons. Get expert insight below!
Andrea W., Golf Expert
Ari T, Golf Expert
Jonathan Belanger, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert Andrea W., Ari T, Jonathan Belanger, Michael V, Gary Neft and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Runner up
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
Runner up
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
Price
from:$599.99
25% off
from:$499.95
30% off
User rating
4.77(360)
4.87(86)
The Curated Take

Best for novice to intermediate golfers due to its extraordinary forgiveness and improved distances.

Best for beginners or golfers struggling with a consistent iron game due to its extreme forgiveness.

Iron Set Type
Iron Set
Iron Set
Player type
Game improvement
Super game improvement
Used (Y/N)
No
No

In the world of golf, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are two top contenders that have been making waves. Both are designed with the beginner and mid-handicap golfer in mind, offering a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel. The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for their game improvement features, easy launch, and smooth feel. On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are praised for their forgiveness, high launch, and offset design that helps correct a slice. Both sets of irons are packed with modern technology and are designed to make the game easier and more enjoyable. However, they differ in their design and performance characteristics, making each set suitable for different types of golfers. The final verdict? It depends on your personal preferences and golfing needs. Read on for a detailed comparison of these two fantastic iron sets.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed with the beginner golfer in mind. These clubs are categorized as “game improvement” irons, making them perfect for those who don't play golf regularly but love the game. The clubs are super easy to hit and feel smooth and crisp, making them a joy to use on the course or at the range.

The SIM2 Max Irons are known for their distance and forgiveness. They are absolute rocket launchers, offering an average 25-yard total distance gain. The clubs are very forgiving on mishit shots, thanks to the forward and low tungsten weighting for higher launch and more distance, and a structured face that helps maintain as much energy from a swing to the ball for better energy transfer.

The clubs also feature a KBS GRAPHITE 80G shaft that is fluid, not too whippy, and not too heavy or stiff. The Lamkin TS1 grip is a favorite among golfers for its softer feel and great vibration dampening when a shot is hit from the club's heel. The clubs also have a higher launch angle and higher spin rates, making them great for players who struggle to keep the ball in the air and are looking for a club with more carry yardage.

However, the SIM2 Max Irons are not designed for workability or shot shaping, which can affect the game of golfers who can work the ball left and right. The sound is also crisp even on mishits, which can be a challenge for mid-handicap players who struggle to differentiate between a good and a bad shot.

If one is looking for a set of clubs that are easy to hit, easy to launch, very forgiving, and have lots of distance, these clubs would be best for them. Overall, this iron set is great for beginners looking for a nice upgraded “game improvement” iron.

Andrea W.
Golf Expert
Best seller

The Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are another great option for mid to high handicap golfers. These irons are designed with an oversized shape, providing a larger footprint without looking like a set of hybrid irons. The increased offset is designed to help golfers who struggle with slicing the golf ball, while the wider sole helps with shots hit fat or behind the golf ball.

The Rogue ST Max OS Irons are known for their distance and forgiveness. The clubs feature a new Cap Back design to promote improved forgiveness, distance, and overall better feel at impact. The AI Flashcup technology gives you higher ball speeds across the face, while the urethane inserts provide a nice solid sound and give you a soft feel on those off-center hits.

The clubs also feature a high launching design, thanks to the KBS Max 85 shafts. The Lamkin Crossline 360 grips provide improved feel and feedback. However, these clubs are not designed for shot shaping, which can be a disadvantage for more advanced players who want to control their shot shape and trajectory.

This is one of the best sets out there for someone who wants a long and forgiving set that helps fight a slice. These have a lot of offset which helps fix a slice but can be bad for someone who moves it left naturally. Very solid feel when hit in the center. Very good performance on mishits.

Ari T
Golf Expert

Similarities

Both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are designed with the beginner and mid-handicap golfer in mind. They both offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel, making them ideal for those looking to improve their game. Both sets of irons are packed with modern technology, such as the TaylorMade's forward and low tungsten weighting and the Callaway's AI Flashcup technology, which are designed to increase ball speed and launch. Both sets also feature high launching designs and grips that provide improved feel and feedback.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both sets of irons are designed for beginner and mid-handicap golfers, they differ in their design and performance characteristics. The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for their game improvement features and easy launch, making them perfect for those who are new to the game or don't play regularly. They are also great for golfers who struggle to keep the ball in the air and are looking for a club with more carry yardage.

On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are designed with an oversized shape and increased offset, making them ideal for golfers who struggle with slicing the golf ball. They also feature a wider sole, which helps with shots hit fat or behind the golf ball. However, these clubs are not designed for shot shaping, which can be a disadvantage for more advanced players who want to control their shot shape and trajectory.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

  1. Forgiveness: Both sets of irons offer high levels of forgiveness, but the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons edge out the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons with their oversized shape and increased offset.
  2. Distance: Both sets of irons are designed to increase ball speed and launch, but the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons take the lead with their game improvement features and easy launch.
  3. Feel: Both sets of irons offer improved feel and feedback, but the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons stand out with their KBS GRAPHITE 80G shaft and Lamkin TS1 grip.
  4. Design: While both sets of irons have sleek designs, the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons win this category with their refined club head design and sleeker look.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are excellent choices for beginner and mid-handicap golfers. They both offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and feel, making them ideal for those looking to improve their game. However, they differ in their design and performance characteristics, making each set suitable for different types of golfers. The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are perfect for those who are new to the game or don't play regularly, while the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are ideal for golfers who struggle with slicing the golf ball. Ultimately, the choice between these two sets of irons comes down to your personal preferences and golfing needs. So, whether you're a beginner looking to improve your game or a mid-handicap golfer looking for a new set of irons, both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons are worth considering.

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get personalized recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$599.99$799.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$499.95$714.30
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$571.40$785.70

Browse more Golf

Callaway Paradym AI Smoke Irons
$1,042.88$1,142.88
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$799.92$1,028.56
Callaway Apex AI300 Irons
$1,200.00
Mizuno JPX925 Hot Metal Irons
$1,049.95
Tour Edge Exotics E723 Irons
$344.99$689.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$914.24$1,257.12
Mizuno JPX923 Hot Metal Irons
$900.00$1,099.95

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy