Expert Comparison: TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set

Published on 02/10/2024 · 7 min readCompare TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set. Get expert insight below!
Andrea W., Golf Expert
Brady Maag, Golf Expert
Michael V, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert Andrea W., Brady Maag, Michael V, Vincent P., Gary Neft and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Runner up
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
Most recommended
Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set
Price
$599.99
25% off
from:$899.99
25% off
User rating
4.78(335)
4.75(4)
The Curated Take

Best for novice to intermediate golfers due to its extraordinary forgiveness and improved distances.

Perfect for mid to high handicappers looking for maximum distance and forgiveness in their shots.

Iron Set Type
Iron Set
Combo Set
Player type
Game improvement
Game improvement
Used (Y/N)
No
No

In the world of golf, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set are two top-tier products that have been making waves. Both sets are designed with the beginner to intermediate golfer in mind, offering a blend of forgiveness, distance, and ease of use. The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for their game improvement features, offering a larger clubface at address, a high launch angle, and a forgiving design that can boost the confidence of higher handicap golfers. On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set is a hybrid set that replaces harder-to-hit long irons with easy-launching hybrids, offering improved distance and spin consistency. While both sets have their strengths, the choice between the two ultimately depends on the golfer's personal preferences and needs.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed with the beginner golfer in mind. These clubs are categorized as “game improvement” irons, making them perfect for those who are just starting out or don't play golf regularly. The clubs are super easy to hit and provide a smooth, crisp feel, making them a joy to use on the course.

The SIM2 Max Irons are designed with a KBS GRAPHITE 80G shaft, which offers a fluid feel without being too whippy or too heavy. This makes them perfect for golfers with a club swing speed of 78 to 84. The clubs also feature a larger clubface at address, which can be a confidence booster for higher handicap golfers.

One of the standout features of the SIM2 Max Irons is their distance. These clubs are absolute rocket launchers, offering an average 25-yard total distance gain. They are also very forgiving on mishit shots, thanks to their forward and low tungsten weighting and structured face. This design helps to maintain as much energy from a swing to the ball for better energy transfer, resulting in more potential distance.

The SIM2 Max Irons also offer a higher launch angle, making them perfect for golfers who struggle to keep the ball in the air and are looking for a club with more carry yardage. They also offer higher spin rates, thanks to their lower center of gravity, which helps golfers keep the ball in the air longer.

Despite their many strengths, the SIM2 Max Irons do have a few drawbacks. They are not designed for workability or shot shaping, which can affect the game of golfers who can work the ball left and right. They also offer a crisp sound even on mishits, which can make it difficult for mid-handicap players to distinguish between good and bad shots.

If one is looking for a set of clubs that are easy to hit, easy to launch, very forgiving, and have lots of distance, these clubs would be best for them. Overall, this iron set is great for beginners looking for a nice upgraded “game improvement” iron.

Andrea W.
Golf Expert

The Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set is a hybrid set that replaces harder-to-hit long irons with easy-launching hybrids. This design offers improved distance and spin consistency, making it a great choice for golfers looking to improve their game.

The Rogue ST Max Combo Set is designed with a unique Flash Face Cup and precision tungsten weighting for optimal spin consistency and maximum forgiveness. The hybrids in the set feature a Jailbreak system for faster ball speeds and high launch, making them perfect for longer shots and off the tee.

One of the standout features of the Rogue ST Max Combo Set is its versatility. The inclusion of hybrids in the set offers increased flexibility on longer shots, making it a great choice for golfers looking for a bit more creativity in their game.

The Rogue ST Max Combo Set also offers a great feel, thanks to the urethane microspheres that provide a soft, pure feel through impact. This can help to improve the overall feel of the shot, allowing golfers to know exactly where on the face they made contact.

Despite its many strengths, the Rogue ST Max Combo Set may not be the best choice for more advanced players. The set offers a lot of forgiveness, but it may not offer the workability that lower handicap players are looking for.

The Callaway Rogue ST Max Iron Hybrid Combo Set is one of the top game improvement sets for 2022. The irons offer maximum forgiveness, distance, and launch. The hybrid is the perfect addition to the set to replace those longer irons and give you more confidence when setting up to strike the ball.

Brady Maag
Golf Expert

Similarities

Both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set are designed with the beginner to intermediate golfer in mind. They both offer a high level of forgiveness, making them perfect for golfers who are still working on their swing and need a bit of help with mishits.

Both sets also offer a high launch angle, which can help golfers who struggle to keep the ball in the air. This can result in more carry yardage and potentially longer shots.

In terms of distance, both sets are designed to offer increased distance. The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for being "absolute rocket launchers," while the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set offers improved distance thanks to its unique Flash Face Cup and precision tungsten weighting.

Both sets also offer a great feel, with the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons featuring a KBS GRAPHITE 80G shaft for a fluid feel, and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set featuring urethane microspheres for a soft, pure feel through impact.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set offer a high level of forgiveness and increased distance, they do have some key differences.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed as a game improvement set, making them perfect for beginner golfers or those who don't play regularly. They offer a larger clubface at address, which can be a confidence booster for higher handicap golfers. However, they are not designed for workability or shot shaping, which can be a drawback for golfers who can work the ball left and right.

On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set is a hybrid set that replaces harder-to-hit long irons with easy-launching hybrids. This makes them a great choice for golfers looking for increased versatility on longer shots. However, they may not offer the workability that lower handicap players are looking for.

In terms of persona, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons would be a great fit for beginner golfers or those who don't play regularly but want a set of clubs that are easy to hit and offer a lot of forgiveness. The Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set would be a great fit for golfers looking for a bit more versatility in their game, with the inclusion of hybrids offering increased flexibility on longer shots.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

  1. Forgiveness: Both sets offer a high level of forgiveness, but the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons may have a slight edge due to their larger clubface at address, which can be a confidence booster for higher handicap golfers.

  2. Distance: Both sets are designed to offer increased distance, but the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for being "absolute rocket launchers," giving them the edge in this category.

  3. Versatility: The Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set takes the win in this category, thanks to its inclusion of hybrids that replace harder-to-hit long irons.

  4. Feel: Both sets offer a great feel, but the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set may have a slight edge due to its urethane microspheres that provide a soft, pure feel through impact.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set are top-tier products that offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and ease of use. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the golfer's personal preferences and needs.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are a great choice for beginner golfers or those who don't play regularly but want a set of clubs that are easy to hit and offer a lot of forgiveness. They offer a larger clubface at address, a high launch angle, and are known for their distance capabilities.

On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set is a hybrid set that replaces harder-to-hit long irons with easy-launching hybrids. This makes them a great choice for golfers looking for increased versatility on longer shots. They also offer improved distance and spin consistency, making them a great choice for golfers looking to improve their game.

In the end, the best set for you will depend on your personal preferences and needs. Whether you're a beginner looking for a set of clubs that are easy to hit, or a more experienced golfer looking for a set that offers increased versatility, both the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set are excellent choices.

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$599.99$799.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max Combo Set
$899.99$1,099.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$799.92$1,142.88

Browse more Golf

Callaway XR Packaged Complete Golf Set
$1,499.99
Callaway Mavrik Irons
$799.95$1,028.56
Callaway 2024 XR Packaged Complete Golf Set
$1,499.99
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$914.24$1,257.12
Cobra LTDx MAX Driver
$199.99$499.00
TaylorMade Stealth Irons
$899.99$1,099.99
Cobra FLY-XL Complete Set
$899.00

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy