Expert Comparison: Wilson D9 Irons vs TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons

Published on 02/11/2024 · 6 min readCompare Wilson D9 Irons and TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons. Get expert insight below!
David L. Brown, Golf Expert
Andrea W., Golf Expert
Ari T, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert David L. Brown, Andrea W., Ari T, Michael V, Laura Kinsman and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Out of stock
Wilson D9 Irons
Out of stock
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
Price
from:$399.99
47% off
from:$514.26
25% off
User rating
4.86(7)
4.77(333)
The Curated Take

Ideal for mid-high handicappers seeking distance and high launch

Best for novice to intermediate golfers due to its extraordinary forgiveness and improved distances.

Iron Set Type
Iron Set
Iron Set
Player type
Game improvement
Game improvement
Used (Y/N)
No
No

In the world of golf, the Wilson D9 Irons and TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are two top contenders that have been making waves. Both sets of irons are designed to enhance your game, but they each have their unique strengths and features. The Wilson D9 Irons are a solid choice for mid to high-tiered handicappers looking to gain more distance in the mid-range game. They offer good forgiveness and a simple sound, but they lack in terms of distance and workability compared to other irons. On the other hand, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed for beginner golfers and are categorized as “game improvement” irons. They offer a higher launch, more forgiveness, and a larger sweet spot. However, they lack workability for big draws and fades. Both sets of irons have their pros and cons, and the choice between the two ultimately depends on your personal preferences and golfing needs.

The Wilson D9 Irons are a fantastic option for golfers looking to improve their mid-range game. These irons are designed with the mid to high-tiered handicapper in mind, offering a solid performance that can help take your game to the next level. The clubs tested had a loft setting of 7 iron - 27 degrees, 9 iron - 37 degrees, with a steel shaft type and regular shaft flex.

The Wilson D9 Irons are known for their forgiveness, thanks to their power sole and head design. Even off-centered hits still travel a good distance and rarely stray 10-20 yards off the target line. The sound of these irons is simple, with a normal tinging noise that isn't ear-piercing. The regular steel flex irons allow for solid, consistent contact, which can boost your confidence as your ball flight goes where you want it to.

However, these irons do have their drawbacks. The distance is comparable to older models like the TaylorMade Racs, but they fall short when compared to the Callaway Rogues and TaylorMade Stealths, averaging 5-10 yards less with each shot. The feel is average at best, with the face not offering much feedback on mishits. The workability is very basic, and the aesthetic appeal leaves much to be desired.

Despite these issues, the Wilson D9 Irons are a good option for someone who does not want to break the bank on an iron set. They are great for the basic golfer looking to improve their game or for someone just starting out.

The Wilson D9 Irons are great for the basic golfer looking to improve their game or would be great for someone just starting. However, I would look elsewhere at the TaylorMade Stealths or Callaway Rogue series for the more serious golfer.

David L. Brown
Golf Expert

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are a game-changer for beginner golfers. These irons are categorized as “game improvement” irons and are designed to make golfing easier and more enjoyable. The clubs tested had a standard loft setting, with a KBS GRAPHITE 80G shaft type and regular shaft flex.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are known for their distance and forgiveness. They are absolute rocket launchers, offering an average of 25-yard total distance gain. The irons are very forgiving on mishit shots, with a performance improvement on centered strike hits. The irons feature a speed bridge for more distance and longer shots, and an echo damping system for improved feel and feedback.

However, these irons do have their drawbacks. The sound is crisp even on mishits, which can give the wrong impression of the ball. The feel is generally softer, but this can be misleading on practice sessions. The workability of these clubs is limited, making them less suitable for advanced players who want to control the ball flight in either direction.

Despite these issues, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are a great value compared to other comparable options. They are perfect for beginners looking for a nice upgraded “game improvement” iron.

The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are a great value compared to other OEM comparable options. I tested these on a Foresight Launch Monitor to provide a true fitting experience. SIM Max, Mizuno HMB, and Titleist T400 irons are the clubs I tested side-by-side. The price point on the Titleist clubs was the highest out of the bunch. TaylorMade won the battle in price and performance out of all three iron head options.

Andrea W.
Golf Expert

Similarities

Both the Wilson D9 Irons and the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed with the goal of improving your golf game. They both offer a good level of forgiveness, making them suitable for golfers who are prone to off-centered hits. Both sets of irons are designed to provide a good level of distance, with the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons offering a bit more distance on average.

Both sets of irons also feature a design that aims to improve the feel of the club during play. The Wilson D9 Irons have a power sole and head design that helps to dampen the feel of off-centered hits, while the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons feature an echo damping system that improves the overall feel of the shot.

In terms of aesthetics, both sets of irons have a professional look that can boost confidence on the course. They both also come with high-quality grips that provide a good level of control during play.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both the Wilson D9 Irons and the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed to improve your game, they cater to different types of golfers. The Wilson D9 Irons are geared towards mid to high-tiered handicappers who are looking to gain more distance in the mid-range game. They offer good forgiveness and a simple sound, but they lack in terms of distance and workability compared to other irons.

On the other hand, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are designed for beginner golfers and are categorized as “game improvement” irons. They offer a higher launch, more forgiveness, and a larger sweet spot. However, they lack workability for big draws and fades.

In terms of aesthetics, the Wilson D9 Irons have a more traditional look, while the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons have a more modern design. The Wilson D9 Irons also have a more basic aesthetic appeal, while the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons have a more flashy design.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

  1. Distance: The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons take the win in this category. They are designed to provide maximum distance, making them perfect for golfers who are looking to add yards to their shots.
  2. Forgiveness: Both sets of irons offer a good level of forgiveness, but the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons edge out the Wilson D9 Irons in this category due to their larger sweet spot and echo damping system.
  3. Feel: The Wilson D9 Irons win in this category. They offer a good feel due to their power sole and head design, which helps to dampen the feel of off-centered hits.
  4. Aesthetics: The TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons take the win in this category. They have a more modern and flashy design compared to the more traditional look of the Wilson D9 Irons.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the Wilson D9 Irons and the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are excellent choices for golfers looking to improve their game. The Wilson D9 Irons are a solid choice for mid to high-tiered handicappers looking for more distance in the mid-range game, while the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons are perfect for beginner golfers looking for a game improvement iron.

While both sets of irons have their strengths and weaknesses, the choice between the two ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and golfing needs. If you're looking for a set of irons that offer good forgiveness and a simple sound, the Wilson D9 Irons might be the right choice for you. However, if you're a beginner golfer looking for a set of irons that offer a higher launch, more forgiveness, and a larger sweet spot, the TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons might be a better fit.

Remember, the best set of irons for you is the one that helps you improve your game and enjoy your time on the course. Happy golfing!

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get free recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

Wilson D9 Irons
$399.99$599.99
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$514.26$685.70
Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$914.24$1,257.12

Browse more Golf

Callaway Mavrik Irons
$514.28$685.68
TaylorMade Stealth Irons
$899.99$1,099.99
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$799.92$1,028.56
Callaway Rogue ST Max OS Irons
$799.99$1,099.99
Callaway Paradym AI Smoke Irons
$1,257.12
TaylorMade Stealth 2 HD Combo Set
$799.99$1,399.99
Wilson D9 Irons
$399.99$749.99

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy