Expert Comparison: TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter vs Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter

Published on 02/12/2024 · 4 min readCompare TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter and Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter. Get expert insight below!
Jonathan Belanger, Golf Expert
Jantzen A., Golf Expert
Martey Hebeler, Golf Expert
Contributed By Golf Expert Jonathan Belanger, Jantzen A., Martey Hebeler, Ari T, Joseph Starr and others

VS

 

Side by side comparison

Most recommended
TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter
Most recommended
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter
Price
$199.99
43% off
$129.99
28% off
Color options
User rating
4.76(29)
4.6(15)
The Curated Take
--

Best for players who prefer a consistent feel and traditional blade putter.

Club Type
Putters
Putters
Used (Y/N)
No
No

In the world of golf, the putter is the most personal club in the bag. Today, we're comparing two top-notch putters: the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter and the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter. Both putters are excellent choices, but they cater to different types of golfers. The TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter is a mallet-style putter with a fantastic alignment system and a well-balanced design, making it a great fit for both high and low handicappers. On the other hand, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter is a traditional blade putter that offers consistent performance and a great feel, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a more classic style. Both putters have their strengths and weaknesses, and the choice between them will largely depend on your personal preferences and playing style.

The TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter is a mallet-style putter that offers excellent balance and alignment. The putter's stark contrast between the white alignment line and the black body makes it easy to line up your putts, which can be a game-changer for golfers who struggle with alignment. The putter's weight is also well-distributed, making lag putting relatively easy.

The putter's aesthetic appeal is another strong point. The black/red/white color scheme is visually striking, and the SuperStroke Traxion 2.0 grip feels great in the hand. The putter's balance is exceptional, producing a smooth stroke that feels fantastic.

However, the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter is not without its flaws. The feel off the face is good but not the best, and the putter is not the most forgiving on mishits. Despite these minor issues, the putter is a good value for its price point, especially when compared to other putters in its class.

This putter is great for golfers who struggle with consistent contact on the putter face. The mallet design and weighting benefits golfers who have a slight arc in their stroke and helps to prevent the face from turning on off-center strikes. This putter helped me gain confidence when putting and I really enjoyed having a long solid white line as the alignment aid.

Jonathan Belanger
Golf Expert

The Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter is a traditional blade putter that offers a consistent performance and a great feel. The putter's milled head is very consistent and high quality, and the plumber's neck design is perfect for golfers with a slight arc to their stroke.

The putter's soft metal provides a great feel, and the milled head puts a great roll on the ball. The putter's sleek look and great alignment aid also add to its appeal. However, the putter may not be the best choice for golfers who prefer a mallet shape.

Despite its lower price point, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter offers excellent performance. The putter's quality and consistency make it an amazing option for its price.

Considering this product is as cheap as it is, you really do get the best bang for your buck. You won't find a quality milled face putter on the market anywhere close to this price range. It looks great at address and feels great off the face.

Jantzen A.
Golf Expert

Similarities

Both the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter and the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter are designed to improve your game on the green. They both offer excellent alignment aids, making it easier to line up your putts. Both putters also have a great feel, with the TaylorMade offering a well-balanced design and the Cleveland providing a soft feel from its metal. Both putters are also designed for golfers with a slight arc in their stroke.

Differences and Who They're Good For

While both putters are excellent choices, they cater to different types of golfers. The TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter, with its mallet design and excellent balance, is a great fit for both high and low handicappers. It's also a good choice for golfers who struggle with alignment.

On the other hand, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter is a traditional blade putter that offers consistent performance and a great feel. It's an excellent choice for golfers who prefer a more classic style and those who value consistency and feel over forgiveness.

Analysis on Who’s the Winner

When it comes to design, the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter takes the cake with its visually striking color scheme and mallet design. For feel, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter wins with its soft metal and consistent milled head. In terms of alignment, the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter's stark contrast between the white alignment line and the black body makes it the clear winner. Finally, for value for money, the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter comes out on top with its high-quality performance at a lower price point.

Conclusions

In conclusion, both the TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter and the Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter are excellent choices, each with their own strengths. The TaylorMade putter shines with its fantastic alignment system and well-balanced design, making it a great fit for both high and low handicappers. The Cleveland putter, on the other hand, offers consistent performance and a great feel, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a more classic style. Ultimately, the choice between these two putters will depend on your personal preferences and playing style. Happy putting!

Curated experts can help

Have a question about the article you just read or want personal recommendations? Connect with a Curated expert and get personalized recommendations for whatever you’re looking for!

Shop Golf on Curated

TaylorMade Spider GT Black #3 Putter
$199.99$349.99
Cleveland Huntington Beach Soft Premier #4 Putter
$129.99$179.99
Mizuno JPX923 Hot Metal Irons
$900.00$1,099.95

Browse more Golf

Callaway Rogue ST Max Irons
$914.24$1,257.12
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Single Iron
$85.71$114.28
Ray Cook Gyro Men's Complete Set
$199.99$349.99
TaylorMade Stealth Irons
$914.28$1,142.85
Callaway XR Packaged Complete Golf Set
$1,399.99
Callaway Paradym Driver
$399.99$599.99
TaylorMade SIM2 Max Irons
$599.99$799.99

Browse more Golf

Read next

New and Noteworthy