Expert Comparison: Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons vs Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons
VS
Side by side comparison |  Top pick! |  Runner up |
|---|---|---|
Price | from:$1,199.99 | from:$771.42 25% off |
User rating | 4.83(216) | 4.96(57) |
The Curated Take | Best for mid-handicappers seeking control, feel and workability while retaining forgiveness and distance. | Best for low to mid-handicap golfers seeking workability and forgiveness. |
Iron Set Type | Iron Set | Iron Set |
Player type | Players distance | Players distance |
Used (Y/N) | No | No |
In the world of golf, the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons and Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are two top contenders. Both are designed for mid-handicap golfers, offering a blend of forgiveness, distance, and workability. The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons are perfect for golfers transitioning from beginner sets, offering a better feel and sound without sacrificing forgiveness. On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are known for their high ball speed and consistency, with a precision tungsten weighting system for optimal launch. While both irons have their strengths, the choice between the two ultimately depends on the golfer's personal preferences and needs.
Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons summary
The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons are a fantastic set for golfers looking to upgrade from their beginner set or game improvement irons. These irons offer a better feel and sound without sacrificing too much forgiveness, making them ideal for mid-handicap golfers. They are designed with a steel - Project X LZ shaft type and an X-Stiff shaft flex, providing a great balance between flexibility and control.
One of the standout features of the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons is their distance. Even when bent 2° weak to match an old set better, these irons fly. They average five yards more of carry for each club, and especially on mishits, these irons deliver distance. They also offer a high level of forgiveness, with the weight pushed to the edges and a slightly thicker topline to help with forgiveness.
The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons also have a great feel. Although they aren't completely forged, they feel amazing, comparable to the TaylorMade P760s. The sound is crisp and muted, and the shaft feel is just right, not too stiff and not too soft. The aesthetic appeal of these irons is also noteworthy. They look great in person, with a layered metal look and sharp lines. They aren't overly bulky but are large enough to give anyone confidence when getting ready to hit a shot.
The Srixon ZX5 MKII set is a great option for golfers looking to graduate from game improvement irons to something that has a better feel, sound, and workability without making golf a chore. These irons perform great and are suitable for most golfers in the mid-handicap range.
The Srixon ZX5 MKII set is a great option for golfers looking to graduate from game improvement irons to something that has a better feel, sound, and workability without making golf a chore. These irons perform great and are suitable for most golfers in the mid-handicap range.
Srixon ZX5 MK II Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons summary
The Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are a mid-handicap distance iron that has extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance. They have a good overall feel coming off the face and are perfect for those needing some distance and a club where one can feel comfortable working the ball.
The Rogue ST Pro irons have a very strong loft to aid in distance, but the weighting in the clubs still launches the ball very nicely. They are surprisingly forgiving for a mid-handicapper iron, with 48 grams of tungsten weighting in the club, which keeps the spin low to moderate—making it a tad difficult to really hit the ball largely off line.
The True Temper Elevate shaft is a mid to low-launching shaft that is standard with the set. At 115 grams, a lighter shaft that can still provide a good trajectory. These irons are a medium to low-spinning iron, but the spin numbers don't drop too drastically. They add five yards of distance to the 7 iron and 5 iron when testing—although it did reduce the spin.
Overall, I recommend these irons for any player needing some extra distance without sacrificing the ability to work the ball. They have the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club; to me, this is the best combo for the mid-handicap golfer.
Overall, I recommend these irons for any player needing some extra distance without sacrificing the ability to work the ball. They have the forgiveness of a player improvement club but the workability of a high-end players club; to me, this is the best combo for the mid-handicap golfer.
Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons
- We price match
- Returnable
Similarities
Both the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are designed with mid-handicap golfers in mind. They both offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and workability, making them ideal for golfers looking to improve their game. Both irons also feature a steel shaft type and an X-Stiff shaft flex, providing a balance between flexibility and control.
In terms of performance, both irons deliver impressive distance and forgiveness. They both have a great feel and sound, and they both offer a high level of workability. Both irons also have a great aesthetic appeal, with a sleek, modern design that looks great in person.
Differences and Who They're Good For
While the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons have many similarities, they also have some key differences. The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons are designed for golfers transitioning from beginner sets, offering a better feel and sound without sacrificing too much forgiveness. They are also known for their distance, even when bent 2° weak to match an old set better.
On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are known for their high ball speed and consistency, with a precision tungsten weighting system for optimal launch. They are a mid-handicap distance iron that has extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance.
The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons are ideal for golfers looking to move out of their beginner set or game improvement irons to something with a better feel and sound without sacrificing too much forgiveness. The Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons, on the other hand, are perfect for golfers needing some distance and a club where one can feel comfortable working the ball.
Analysis on Who’s the Winner
When comparing the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons, it's clear that both sets have their strengths. However, in terms of distance, the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons take the lead. They offer impressive distance, even when bent 2° weak to match an old set better.
In terms of forgiveness, both sets perform well, but the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons have a slight edge due to their precision tungsten weighting system. This system provides improved launch conditions and maximizes speed across the face.
When it comes to workability, both sets offer a high level of control, allowing golfers to shape their shots as needed. However, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are known for their high ball speed and consistency, which may give them a slight advantage in this category.
Finally, in terms of feel and sound, the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons stand out. They offer a better feel and sound compared to many other irons, making them a great choice for golfers who value these aspects.
Conclusions
In conclusion, both the Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons and the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are excellent choices for mid-handicap golfers. They both offer a blend of forgiveness, distance, and workability, making them ideal for golfers looking to improve their game. However, the choice between the two ultimately depends on the golfer's personal preferences and needs.
The Srixon ZX5 MKII Irons are perfect for golfers transitioning from beginner sets, offering a better feel and sound without sacrificing too much forgiveness. They are also known for their distance, even when bent 2° weak to match an old set better.
On the other hand, the Callaway Rogue ST Pro Irons are known for their high ball speed and consistency, with a precision tungsten weighting system for optimal launch. They are a mid-handicap distance iron that has extra weighting in the perimeter to add ball speed to the clubhead and increase distance.
In the end, both sets are excellent choices, and the decision will ultimately come down to the individual golfer's preferences and needs.
