Most recommended / Fishing
Most Recommended Fly Reels under $250
Updated

Sometimes you need great fly reels on a budget. Curated experts make sure to take each fisher's budget into account every time they make recommendations. This list brings together their top recommendations for fly reels under $250. Want a more personalized pick? Don't forget to talk to a Fly Fishing expert for free advice and recommendations on the best reels for your needs.

Result summary
  1. Orvis Hydros Fly Reels
  2. Redington Behemoth Series Fly Reel
  3. Redington Run Reel
  4. Sage Spectrum C Fly Reel
  5. Redington Rise Series Fly Reels
  6. Lamson Liquid Fly Reel
  7. Orvis Clearwater LA Reel
  8. Lamson Remix Fly Reel
  9. Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel
  10. Redington Zero Series Reel
1
Orvis Hydros Fly Reels
#1 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Orvis

Orvis Hydros Fly Reels

From $249.00

The Hydros series is perfect for novice and expert anglers looking to step up performance without breaking the bank. This is a lightweight large arbor reel with a fully sealed clutch bearing drag. Quick line retrieval and has a low start-up inertia which is great for hot fish in the fresh and salt.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Sep 15, 2022

All around trout - even and especially when you have to put a good size fish on the reel! Durable, dependable, and a great drag ratio!

Fly Fishing Expert Ryan Peters
Ryan Peters
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Sep 15, 2022

Rated for rods 3-5wt. Overall solid performance with good durability.

Fly Fishing Expert Jeff Henderson
Jeff Henderson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Sep 16, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
gear
gear
gear
gear
gear
gear
gear
gear
Curated
Which gear is right for you?
Get free recommendations from a certified gear expert. Take a short quiz to get started!
2
Redington Behemoth Series Fly Reel
#2 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Redington

Redington Behemoth Series Fly Reel

From $129.99

A heavy-duty, durable real that will be perfect with a 7/8 rod! Super versatile reel that will allow you to fish both fresh and salt water without a problem. A great option that is affordable. comes in a variety of colors! Good for big trout to bass, pike, salt water fish.

Fly Fishing Expert Jeff Henderson
Jeff Henderson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Perfect size for 5wt rod - will hold plenty of backing and fly line. Large arbor means super fast pick up speed when reeling in fish!

Fly Fishing Expert Lawson T.
Lawson T.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Great for trout, bass, carp, panfish. Solid drag.

Fly Fishing Expert Elijah Saint Blancard
Elijah Saint Blancard
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$129.99
Cabela's+ free shipping$129.99
Backcountry.com+ free shipping$129.99
3
Redington Run Reel
#3 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Redington

Redington Run Reel

$119.99

This is a die-cast reel, which will not be as light as machined aluminum, but offers tremendous stopping power and durability for the price. A good entry level reel for large freshwater species and smaller inshore species in the salt.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Smooth stopping power, quick line retrieval, very lightweight, smooth drag, interchangeable spools. Large arbor design, compact carbon fiber drag system.

Fly Fishing Expert Jesi Scott
Jesi Scott
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Super lightweight - only 5.8 oz. Awesome carbon drag system that will handle anything that comes its way! Designed for both fresh and salt water.

Fly Fishing Expert Jeff Henderson
Jeff Henderson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
4
Sage Spectrum C Fly Reel
#4 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Sage

Sage Spectrum C Fly Reel

From $165.00

Good for everything freshwater. Small streams and rivers up to very large rivers like the Missouri. The spectrum has an incredible drag system which gives flawless line to reel transition to keep those big fish on the end of your line.

Fly Fishing Expert Jake A
Jake A
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

The large arbor design gives you fast line pickup. Great all-around trout reel that is reliable over many trips.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Will handle any fish with ease. Aluminum construction ensures it is built to last.

Fly Fishing Expert Bob P.
Bob P.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
5
Redington Rise Series Fly Reels
#5 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Redington

Redington Rise Series Fly Reels

From $219.99

Machined aluminum for the perfect balance of weight and durability, a U-shaped arbor to stack line more effectively, and a carbon fiber drag system that stops torque in the reel.

Fly Fishing Expert Boone Tullett
Boone Tullett
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Very lightweight. Compact carbon fiber drag system, should make for smooth fish stopping! Oversize drag. Fully machined for high-class feel.

Fly Fishing Expert Andrew Pfaffinger
Andrew Pfaffinger
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Great salt, fish stopping drag. Great price, super lightweight, large arbor.

Fly Fishing Expert Elijah Saint Blancard
Elijah Saint Blancard
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
6
Lamson Liquid Fly Reel
#6 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Waterworks-Lamson

Lamson Liquid Fly Reel

From $139.99

Any freshwater application. Smooth, conical drag system. Large arbor design. A lot of the components are CNC machined here in the US and the reel is assembled in Boise Idaho.

Fly Fishing Expert Tellan Lloyd
Tellan Lloyd
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Lamson reels tend to have a very smooth drag, and don't "click" much when you reel them in. These reels have the backbone to deal with any trout that you may encounter.

Fly Fishing Expert Aaron Tate
Aaron Tate
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

It has an adequate, large arbor that will harbor more fly line and backing than you will ever need. Fits nicely both size wise and aesthetically onto the Path II.

Fly Fishing Expert Andrew Bowen
Andrew Bowen
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Cabela's+ free shipping$139.99
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$139.99
7
Orvis Clearwater LA Reel
#7 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Orvis

Orvis Clearwater LA Reel

From $98.00

Smooth, easily adjustable drag, and lightweight build allow you to dial in your drag settings while playing many different sized fish. Pairs well with the 5wt Clearwater Fly Rod.

Fly Fishing Expert Austin Wilt
Austin Wilt
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

This is great for trout/bass/bluegill - just about any species you would be targeting on a 5wt rod.

Fly Fishing Expert Tommy Stornant
Tommy Stornant
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Great starter reel with a lot of line capacity. Easy to use and very durable.

Fly Fishing Expert David W.
David W.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$98.00
Cabela's+ free shipping$98.00
Stillwater Fly Shop+ free shipping$98.00
8
Lamson Remix Fly Reel
#8 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Waterworks-Lamson

Lamson Remix Fly Reel

From $229.99

The -9+ is an excellent reel for heavy freshwater applications - steelhead, salmon, pike, musky - and 9-11 weight saltwater rods.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$229.99
Cabela's+ free shipping$229.99
9
Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel
#9 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Orvis

Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel

From $129.00

I cannot recommend this reel enough. It is perfect for anything from small streams to medium sized rivers. Its simple mechanics allow you to focus less on things like drag, and more on line management and control. Hiking long distances to water and negotiating woody areas, you'll come to appreciate the ultra-light, minimal nature of this. For small streams and rocky rivers, you'll want a reel that can withstand the conditions. If you find yourself climbing, skirting, bouldering, and crawling to get to some of those waters, you need something that can withstand more than a few bumps and scrapes. With its solid aluminum build, it still looks and performs like new after years of abuse. Unlike heavier duty drag reels out there, the click-pawl mechanics put you in control and make a killer classic sound when you have a fighter on your line. It's a wonderful way to fish. This is a generational piece of gear you can expect to pass on some day.

Fly Fishing Expert Hayden B.
Hayden B.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Very simple design, quality construction. It has a narrow spool which prevents line stacking, and its easily adjustable for left or right hand retrieve.

Fly Fishing Expert Jake Williams
Jake Williams
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Cabela's+ free shipping$129.00
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$129.00
Backcountry.com+ free shipping$129.00
10
Redington Zero Series Reel
#10 in the Top 10 Fly Reels under $250
Redington

Redington Zero Series Reel

From $99.99
$109.99
Up to 9% off

This is perfect for hiking in on small streams that come down from the Rocky Mountains. Great entry level equipment.

Fly Fishing Expert Franklin Jones
Franklin Jones
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
Honorable mentions
Orvis Battenkill Disc Reel
Orvis

Orvis Battenkill Disc Reel

From $169.00

Fresh water or salt water fishing on 5-7 weight rods. Another classic 5-weight fly reel that Orvis has been producing for 70 years. This is another reel that will last you a lifetime with the classic trout reel styling. Super smooth drag system that is fully sealed when the spool is engaged. You just cannot go wrong with this reel for this price point.

Fly Fishing Expert Baily Dent
Baily Dent
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

The Orvis Battenkill Disc reel features the same drag and arbor system as higher-end models and is well-suited for trout streams and lakes alike! It is a 5-7 weight, so it will work well for trout (5wt) and bass/lake trout (7wt). With old-school looks, don't underestimate the Battenkill line of reels! This updated version features new internals taken from higher-end reels, all packaged into a classic look. Smooth drag and adjustability makes it easy to land any fish within its weight range!

Fly Fishing Expert Jake Vellinga
Jake Vellinga
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$169.00
Trout's Fly Fishing+ free shipping$169.00
Redington I.D Series Reel
Redington

Redington I.D Series Reel

From $85.99

For the price, its hard to beat! Smooth line collection and a larger arbor makes it much easier to collect line when fish is on. Will set nicely on your rod selection. All around good choice!

Fly Fishing Expert Chase Chapman
Chase Chapman
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

A sturdy cast aluminum construction, smooth rulon disc drag, and larger arbor. Speedy line retrieve, customization decals, very low price point.

Fly Fishing Expert Jesi Scott
Jesi Scott
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Holding your line and getting big fish to the net. I am frequently surprised by the smoothness and reliability of the drag on this reel.

Fly Fishing Expert Aaron Tate
Aaron Tate
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
Cheeky - Limitless 375 Spool
Cheeky

Cheeky - Limitless 375 Spool

From $159.00

This is an excellent trout reel that is best paired with a 5 or 6 weight. If you plan in sticking some monsters - you'll be glad you have the reliable drag system to slow them down! This is a brute of a reel that is very durable. Has a die cast casing but the spool and other components are CNC machined to reduce weight.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

Solid reel with a nice flash and a great price. Good for 7+ weight rods.

Fly Fishing Expert Wilson Jones
Wilson Jones
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Bass Pro Shops+ free shipping$159.00
Cabela's+ free shipping$159.00
CampSaver.com+ free shipping$159.00
Redington Rise Series Spare Spool
Redington

Redington Rise Series Spare Spool

$109.99

This reel can handle any trout application outside of streamer fishing.

Fly Fishing Expert John T.
John T.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Sep 16, 2022
Backcountry.com+ free shipping$109.99
Lamson Remix HD Fly Reel
Waterworks-Lamson

Lamson Remix HD Fly Reel

From $249.99

One of the best reels in this price range hands down! Made completely in the USA with one of the best drag systems on the market! This beast will handle anything you hook into! Large arbor, quick retrieve, lots of power.

Fly Fishing Expert joshua parke
joshua parke
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
Lamson Liquid 3-Pack Fly Reel and 2 Spare Spools
Waterworks-Lamson

Lamson Liquid 3-Pack Fly Reel and 2 Spare Spools

From $219.99

The Lamson Liquid is a fantastic reel at an excellent value. Lamson makes some of the most durable reels on the market, and the Liquid offers a sealed, conical drag and an aluminum frame and spool. Perfect for budget-conscious anglers who want be able to fish a variety of tactics and different line without purchasing an entirely new reel.

Fly Fishing Expert Kendrick Wilson
Kendrick Wilson
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022

This is good for having multiple options to fish above or below the water. It provides the option to load different lines to fish top water as well as deep with a sink link.

Fly Fishing Expert Jonathan Graham
Jonathan Graham
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Jul 13, 2022
Backcountry.com+ free shipping$219.99
Redington Crosswater Series Reel
Redington

Redington Crosswater Series Reel

From $59.99

This reel comes pre spooled with line and ready to fish. All you will have to do is tie on a fly!

Fly Fishing Expert Wade D.
Wade D.
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Dec 7, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
Sage Spectrum Spare Spool
Sage

Sage Spectrum Spare Spool

From $150.00

The Spectrum is a well-made durable reel from Sage. At 4.7oz, this is a lightweight reel, but still has the strength to land the bigger ones! It is designed with a large arbor for quick line retrieval, and the arbor is concave for added strength

Fly Fishing Expert Blake Thomas
Blake Thomas
Verified Fly Fishing Expert • Reviewed Sep 15, 2022
We haven't found this product listed elsewhere. If you find a lower price, let your expert know - we'll match it!
Why you can trust this list

Curated Experts don’t get paid by the manufacturer to write these reviews. All of their opinions are their own and unbiased. Want to learn more about our experts? Check out the video or view some of their profiles to learn more!

Meet the Curated Experts
FAQ
Our experts earn money for each customer they help. They earn the same commission regardless of which brands they sell, so their recommendations are completely unbiased. Also, most shoppers love their expert’s advice so much that they choose to leave an optional tip!
Getting fitted by an expert is easy. Complete a short quiz to tell us about yourself and what you’re looking for, we’ll match you with an expert, and your expert will guide you to the right gear.
Learn more
It’s absolutely free! Seriously. You’ll just pay for any products you buy.
A collage of people skiing, snowboarding, playing golf, camping, hiking and fly fishing.
Still have questions?
Click below to chat with an expert — it’s free!